The hotel lacked amenities, one of its elevators do not work, the card reader for the working elevator did not work consistently, the front desk staff was not the easiest to work with, and the rooms smelled.

We complained several times about the lingering smell of marijuana and smoke in our room and in the hallways, and elevator.

However it was so small we had Troy Le navigating around the bed and it was situated beside the elevators.

I took the elevator down to ground only to discover steps
The store is on the main level

Marijuana blunts on the floors and in elevator.

The smell of Marijuana was on the elevator and on the floor.

No bell man no valet no luggage carts was stuck in elevator fir 15 minutes all the linen was yellow stained just the worse

You will get a contact high standing in the elevator.

Finally on our second day they opened a corridor that led to the conference center and we could use their elevators

The only plus side to this stay is that both elevators we’re working this time.

Between the squeaky elevator, the roach, the condition of the room, and the hallways reeking of ganja, this was utterly ridiculous.

Besides the miserable staff that couldn't make eye contact or smile the hotel had a stench of vomit mixed with dirty Bong water, maybe people like to bake out the elevators & get so High that they then vomit on the floor once they arrive on their floor.

Of two elevators - one is broken making long waits.

but one of the elevators was broken causing a long wait time.

Filthy, busted furniture, smoke smelling rooms, pot odor everywhere, halls, elevator seeping into the room.

Horrible parking, they lost my car keys, two elevators when the hotel was completely booked, staff told us there were no stairs.

Also in order to ride the elevator you need to use the room card i wasn't told that took me a minute to figure it out.

-	Elevator and many areas of the hotel smell like weed.

2) Parking is now 20ish $ whereas in 2008, it was free.

though a poster at the P4 Hotel Shuttle picj up place at Newark aiurport says breakfast is free of charge, this is not true.

unless you are stranded and homeless and offered to stay there for free . .

Loved it I would recommend on any given day possible, extremely comfortable and stress free environment,it's a lot of channels to watch and a decent side television, a real nice friendly staff that's on point with Five star service,

Advertising free breakfast there wasn’t any free breakfast!

On the positive side, the rooms are decent and are fairly up to date and they have a free shuttle to the Newark airport.

Many people have commented on the great free breakfast.

Very nice hotel operate a free shuttle bus back and to the airport/Penn station 24 hours which was fantastic.

Ended up staying here after a flight delay, they operate a free shuttle bus back and too to the airport 24 hours which was fantastic as we were quite late arriving.

The hotel has a lot of history and serves free breakfast enough to fill you up to start the day.

I booked this hotel because it had free breakfast and a free airport shuttle to EWR.

Penn Station in NYC at 33rd its the perfect spot for travel if you don't want to pay city prices for hotels and free breakfast daily its just right .

The hotel has a free shuttle to Newark Airport and Penn Station.

Also the free shuttle from the Newark airport was a add on.

Oh, and if you are a vegetarian/vegan good luck with the free breakfast - not too much to choose from there.

Asides from that, the hotel is in a good location from the train station for travel to New York etc, and the hotel offers a free shuttle bus.

Staff was lovely, free shuttle to and from the airport.

The hotel looks good from the outside, and the free shuttle from the airport is fast.

It had a free shuttle from Newark Airport and that was quite convenient.

Free shuttle, free breakfast, friendly staff, clean

The free shuttle runs every 30 minutes to the airport and Penn Station.

We wanted to take the train into NYC one day, and someone in our group could not walk far, so we wanted to take advantage of the free shuttle.

The hotel provides a free shuttle from the airport & the two near by train stations.

There was a free shuttle that picked us up from the airport so that was a good thing.

It was really reasonable, and even to include a free shuttle ride to and from the airport!

I called from EWR for the free shuttle and it arrived in 10 minutes.

we were able to check in early and that together with a free shuttle service were the only good things during this stay.

It's very close to Newark's Penn Station (and has a free shuttle), from which your trip to Manhattan is 20 minutes!

It is close to Newark airport and has 24-hour free shuttle service to the airport.

Free shuttle service to Penn station and airport every half an hour.

Used this Hotel as rate was good and it had a free shuttle service to and from Newark airport.

Just boiled eggs and a pre-packaged sausage burger.

The breakfast is good enough with hot pancake machine, hot cereals, other various options.

Great breakfast included including hot cereal, eggs, pancakes, breakfast sandwiches.

Hotel serves hot breakfast and have plenty of options.

Breakfast was included, boiled eggs, pancakes, grits, breakfast sandwiches, cereals, fresh fruit etc.. the breakfast rooms were always full it was a busy spot.

The free breakfast was mediocre, the boiled eggs were the best thing on there.

Breakfast place offered great choices (boiled eggs, pancakes, toasts. ).

Breakfast had a few hot choices beyond the standard continental breakfast offerings, and was perfectly acceptable, if nothing special.

Breakfast was generous and there were newspapers, magazines and TV in the breakfast room with the best hot egg and sausage sandwiches!

Hot eggs, miniburgers or mini-eggsandwiches, regular toast, muffins and the like and six kinds of cerials.

They had boiled eggs, waffles, breads, muffins, cereal, coffee, juices, some fruit.

Amenities include hot as well as continental breakfast.

The hotel was clean, the staff was friendly, the breakfast was pretty good, lots of variety of things, pancakes, egg sandwiches, yogurt, coffee, juice, baked good, toaster, boiled eggs, oatmeal.

The complimentary continental breakfast was quite good --- oatmeal, toast, pancakes, boiled eggs, yogurt, bagels, muffins, pastry, etc.

1) free continental breakfast(oats, egg/sausage muffins, cereals, toast, bagel, hard boiled eggs, fruits).

A complimentary breakfast was included, and there was a decent variety of choices including coffee, juice, pre-made biscuit sandwiches, fruit, boiled eggs.

The continental breakfast was better than I expected, and I was surprised to find they offered hard boiled eggs and oatmeal, which offered a little bit more substance then the bagels.

A satisfactory continental breakfast, including some brand name cereals, hard boiled eggs, fruit and bagels is offered in the morning.

Great to reach NYC on Path Train from Newark Penn Station.

Next door to NJPAC and walking distance to Prudential Center, Nike Store and Newark Penn Station.

The shuttle from the hotel to Newark Penn Station was very convenient, they also offer a shuttle from Penn Station to the hotel which I wish I knew ahead of time

A 15 minute walk to Newark Penn Station or use the hotel shuttle bus.

It saved us a small fortune on taxi fares to and from Newark Penn Station,

Stayed at this hotel twice Sept 2012 and 2014 both were a pleasure it's an alternative stay if your on a budget free breakfast business center and Newark Penn station just down the street (a skip and a hop to the city ) comfy beds spacious rooms and a roof top terrace that overlooks new York city great hotel at budget reasonable price strongly recommend

It included being picked up at the airport, getting a ride to Newark Penn Station, and breakfast.

The hotel is 4 blocks from the Newark Penn Station PATH train station.

Newark Penn Station is about 15 minutes walk away and the area seemed pretty safe.

Positives:
Good value (cheap), compared to other hotels, especially those near or in NYC
Close to Newark Penn Station, about 10 minutes to walk
Neighborhood seems to be safe (perhaps much safer than years ago)
On-demand shuttle service (note: the service is on-demand.

The Robert Treat Hotel has nice accommodations, friendly staff, good breakfast and is conveniently located walking distance to Newark Penn Station in the heart of downtown Newark.

Pros:  
Shuttle bus to Newark Penn station and back, which was great.

We used the complimentary shuttle to and from Newark Penn station and it made getting into NYC very easy.

though old well maintained hotel near Newark penn station which makes it convenient to get into NYC.

It’s conveniently located near Newark Penn Station (12 minutes walk or a 6$ Uber ride), & 1 PATH ride away from NYC (25 min travel time).

Super convenient to Prudential Center (NJ Devils) and Newark Penn Station to go into NYC, which is usually what I'm there for (one of those two, usually both).

Well located property in downtown, with convenient scheduled shuttle to airport / Newark Penn Station.

It's a 5-10 min easy walk to Newark Penn Station.

800m walking distance or get the hotel shuttle to the Newark Penn Station.

When I arrived to the hotel the staff was extremely nice and guided me to where to park instructions were simple and straight forward.

And there is an underground parking lot across the street in the park.

I loved the scenery across from the historic military park.. great location and parking was very easy and secure..security was good with room and elevator access connected to card..the front desk staff was very helpful and the driver of shuttle was very helpful and convenient

The view is OK if you are on high floor, of the park in front.

The hotel is located in downtown Newark so it’s a very mixed area and right across the street from a small park.

Got a corner view overlooking the park - very nice.

The Robert Treat Hotel, BW Premier Collection is near these landmarks: Red Bull Arena, Bethlehem Judah Christian Church, Richard W. DeKorte Park, Brunswick Zone, Turtle Back Zoo, Ghost Hawk Brewing, Liberty State Park, To the Struggle Against World Terrorism, Two Ton Brewing, The Warren, Trinity Church, GUIDED TOUR OF NEW YORK CITY / GENERAL, John Russell Wheeler Park, Nomahegan Park, Church of St. Michael the Archangel, Altamarea, The Church of Ascension, The Strand, Monahan's CLUB, La Caverna Art Gallery, The Church of St Mary the Virgin, Brix City Brewing, Discover France, Cool Spa, Jade Island, Imagine That!

The night scenery from the rooms is amazing with an iconic view of the city of newark and the park.

The surrounding area (it's right next door to Military Park) is nice.

There’s a nice park and a Whole Foods nearby.

There is a new Whole Foods just across the park, which is one of your best bets for good food.

Whole Foods Store and Starbucks across the park.

We needed a hotel were we could park our car within a short walk to the train station.

The room with view on the park was excellent, the bed a little gift, after all our packing for international moving.

Being able to park my car was a huge plus.

The area has a nice little park in front of it and pretty decent area with colleges around.

There's a nice park across the street as well as a Whole Foods.

Our room was on 12th floor overlooking a park and church.

We had a great room on the 11th floor with a view of the park and the old church.

but foul is the only way I could describe the smell in the hallway that seemed to be coming from the carpet is my guess.

but smelled of cigarette smoke from past occupants.

And called down during the night when we could smell someone smoking.

There was a stale cigarette smoke odor in the room.

I think someone is smoking near the vents because our room as well as others reeked of weed the entire stay.

Old mildew non professional dilapidated under construction hotel with wind blowing through the hotel lobby since the entire front entrance was missing the staff was a bunch of non professional at night.

The entire floor to my room smelled like a 50 year old ash tray.

Other cons:
- room smelled strongly of cloves
- no cups
- there's a coffee maker

Room smells  bad, marks of cigarettes in the side table it’s disgusting.

Robert Treat Hotel, BW Premier Collection

smell

elevator

newark-penn-station

park

free shuttle

Breakfast was included and was adequate (hard boiled eggs, waffle maker, cereal, juice, coffee/tea, fruit, yogurt).

Breakfast was more than adequate with a range of cereals and instant porridge, pastries, bagels, waffles, fruit, yogurt and hard boiled eggs & fruit juice.

Unripe bananas, Trix flavored yogurt (strawberry and VERY sweet), stack of frozen Eggo waffles, hard boiled eggs in a crockpot, dry pastries.

Breakfast included waffles and warm boiled eggs.

The free breakfasts were basic, doughnuts, hard boiled eggs, muffins, yogurt, juice, coffee and tea.

Free breakfast - it's a very basic breakfast (yogurt, fruit, toast, hard boiled eggs, cereal, coffee, etc)

There were fabulous, fresh NY bagels, donuts and muffins every morning along with juices, fresh fruit, had boiled eggs, yogurt, cold cereals, oatmeal and coffee.

croissants, cereal, doughnuts, tea, coffee, juices and boiled eggs and yoghurts etc.

We had breakfast included and found bagels, jams, cream cheese, boiled eggs, cereals and donuts.

Soft boiled eggs/toast/bagels/fruit/yogurt.

White bagels, white bread, donuts, muffins, waffles, 2 cereals, yogurt, hard boiled eggs, watered down juice, apples and bananas.

but we found it to be ample, with lots of choices from fresh fruit and yogurt, to boiled eggs, to waffles and pancakes, and, our favourite, amazing bagels.

but adequate and kept us full until lunchtime each day for no additional cost - bagels and toast with cream cheese, yoghurts, donuts, boiled eggs, oatmeal pots and tea, coffee and orange juice.

Breakfast was high in carbs with pancakes, waffles, donuts, bagels, fresh fruit and hard boiled eggs.

They include a continental breakfast which included waffles, pancakes, hard boiled eggs, yogurt, apples, oranges bananas, muffins bagels, cereal, milk juice coffee and tea.

My only complaint was the breakfast buffet. I love a salty breakfast and they only offered boiled eggs, toast &

Breakfast included yogurt, muffins, pancakes, waffles, boiled eggs, donuts, oatmeal, tea, juice and coffee.

Breakfast is okay if you re not picky; bread, pancakes, doughnuts , waffles, bagels, jams, boiled eggs, yogurts, cereals, coffee, juices and fruits.

The donuts were great, there are also bagels, hard boiled eggs and yogurt.

One elevator was pretty reserved in morning times.

but still pretty clean
Good breakfast

Cons:
This is a small hotel, one elevator and one very narrow stairwell (the stairwell is important as it comes into play below).

The only negatives:  there's only one elevator, and it seems to move at a snail's pace, so I opted for the stairs most of the time.

The hallway outside of the elevator is also so slim that only 4 people can wait in the hallway for an elevator.

Only one elevator which sometimes resulted in long waits.

although there was no hint of smoke, made our way downstairs (literally, not using the elevator) to the lobby, where the night manager sheepishly confessed to the cause of our rude awakening.

), only one slow elevator, my room only had a desk chair--no other chair, lobby was not very comfortable or inviting, paper-thin walls (if you’re unlucky, you’ll have lots of people letting their room doors slam shut, and you’ll hear every one), bathrooms have shower gel dispensers instead of actual soap.

The elevator was not the quickest, sometimes you had to wait couple of minutes , as it served all 9 floors and lower level.

While waiting to get on the elevator we heard one of the front desk staff say it would be 3 or 4 hours.

We had a hard time making the turn out of the elevator into the hallway, with our suitcases, were you are meet by a door as soon as you make that turn.

Only suggestion would be to look into possibly adding a 2nd elevator,

One tiny elevator, I can't imagine how it is on busy days

Elevator extremely small -- definitely not for the claustrophobic!!

A few reviews on here said elevator was too small and slow we fit myself I am average my husband who is 6'2" 240lbs (football player build)  a teenage boy and our 10 year olds and bags we were fine who cares if it's slow you're on a getaway/vacation I need to point this out sorry.

Stayed at this Hotel for 4 nights, check in was quick & hassle free.

Our room was upgraded because of the long stay and were given late checkout and free baggage service.

The cold water machine in the gym was a nice bonus.

Clean room, comfortable bed, friendly staff, free continental breakfast, free wifi, free luggage hold so we could check out and continue our adventures the day we were leaving, and not have to carry our luggage around the city!

Hotel offers Free wifi and continental breakfast.

There was free wi-fi and a continental breakfast as well.

But the real bonus here is the amazing, helpful and welcoming staff.

Clean room and free continental breakfast.

Check in was easy, the free breakfast had enough of a selection that everyone in my family was happy and all the sites we planned to see this visit were within walking distance!!

but they would check my bags free of charge.

We had taken Amtrak up to see two shows and to enjoy the restaurants, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Frick and Friday night free jazz at the Morgan Library.

Complimentary Daily Breakfast and Free WiFi.

it's 2 blocks away from Times Square + free wifi + free breakfast
The bad: my room,

Continental breakfast was a great way to start the day.Contrary to some other reviews we really enjoyed the free breakfast.

Loved hotel and Hospitality..nice free breakfast and free wifi.. Great location.

Even so, I must say I was pleasantly surprised by the great location, clean and up to date room, free wifi, etc.

Breakfast was good, and it is included, as well as free wifi.

There was free wifi and facility to print documents if required.

Queen sized beds were wonderfully comfortable.Well maintained facility,free Internet, helpful staff.

The price was very good for this location, free wifi throughout, free continental breakfast inc' eggs and porridge.

), free wi-fi in the rooms and a computer in the lobby.

The free breakfast & free wi-fi were a plus!

but the room still got good light. The wifi was free, good and fast (we were on 5th floor.)

Love having a microwave and fridge and free wifi.

On the plus side the bed was reasonably comfortable, there was an empty fridge and microwave which would be useful if staying a few days, and free WiFi.

I stayed for 6 days and was fed up of eating a boiled egg daily.

inedible hot food/stale coffee and stale bread) and the bellmen who would store your luggage no problem

What else, fitness room small and trendmill was out or order,

Rooms are very small, reception was staff not friendly, they charged for storing the luggage, the breakfast was limited

Secondly, the rooms were very tiny and no bar fridge for milk for your coffee or cold drink.

Some reviews said that this hotel had small rooms,

Sadly on arrival we were given a very small room with the view being a brick wall about 6 feet from the window so pretty much no daylight was key in at all.

Rooms are small without feeling confined.

The room was small as expected for new york hotel rooms

The breakfast continental buffet is really good and has a great variety (eggs, toasts, croissant, bagels, waffles, cereals).

I can tell you that the former owners provided an outstanding breakfast (bagels, cereal, hard-boiled eggs, donuts & sweet breads, pre-made waffles, bananas/apples, yogurt, orange juice, tea, and coffee from 6 am-10 am.

- an included breakfast (bagels, toasts, donuts, muffins, waffles, fruits..), so you can start your day with a full stomach.

The breakfast area was very simple filled with donuts, coffee, bagels, cereal, and waffles.

The breakfast consisted of cereals, doughnuts, toast, bagels, apples, bananas, waffles, coffee, and juices.

Fresh bagels, donuts, breads, oatmeal, fresh fruit, yogurt, waffles and pancakes and more.

The breakfast was pancakes, waffles, cereal etc.

but I thought the price per night was great, especially since it also includes breakfast (which is also decent - toast, bagels, waffles, pancakes, cereal, so plenty of options).

Breakfast is included and we dined on waffles, pancakes and doughnuts (not very healthy) every morning and the breakfast "man" was absolutely lovely, as were all the staff.

but there were eggo-style waffles and hard-boiled eggs available.

The free confidential breakfast did not skimp on options and included fresh donuts, cereal, waffles, yogurt, fruit and a variety of other choices.

Breakfast was ok.  they had a choice of waffles and pancakes both of which I found dry.

Nov, 27, 2022

Sep, 10, 2022

Aug, 13, 2022

Jul, 14, 2022

May, 9, 2022

Feb, 19, 2020

Nov, 15, 2022

Sep, 25, 2022

Apr, 25, 2023

Apr, 3, 2023

Dec, 11, 2023

Dec, 4, 2023

Oct, 24, 2023

May, 21, 2023

Jul, 26, 2023

Jul, 23, 2023

Apr, 21, 2023

Apr, 17, 2023

Jul, 26, 2020

Dec, 12, 2019